Browse: Challenging Perceptions - Women Artists in Gilcrease Collection
Rarely before seen or discussed together, women artists are represented across time and culture in the Gilcrease collection. Because the work of women artists has largely been ignored in many art historical analyses, their work is often not well-known or appreciated. However, closer examinations of art created in recent centuries by today’s art historians has led to recognition of women artists and their importance in many different contexts throughout history. Notable women artists featured in the Gilcrease collections include Rosa Bonheur, Mary Cassatt, Maria Martinez, Ila Mae McAfee, Mary Nimmo Moran, Nampeyo, Georgia O’Keeffe, Margaret Tafoya, Kay Walkingstick, and Constance Whitney Warren.
The Gilcrease collection provides a strong cross-cultural sampling that demonstrates the contributions women artists have made to the evolution of art-making in their respective realms, in both Native American and Euro-American cultures.
Although popular for its large holdings of Thomas Moran’s work, Gilcrease Museum also houses a large collection of etchings, prints, drawings, ink washes, sketchbooks, and original copper plates produced by Thomas’s wife, Mary Nimmo Moran. Mary’s artwork is one of the largest bodies of work by a female artist in Gilcrease collections, and presents a remarkable comprehensive view of the artist’s process from inception to completion. Noted as a well-respected mid-19th century printmaker, she was the only woman to become a member of the original 65 fellows at London’s Royal Society of Painters and Etchers. In addition to accolades by English art critic John Ruskin, Mary Moran was also elected to membership in the Society of Painters and Etchers of New York.
Perhaps the most famous animalier artist of the 19th century was French realist painter, Rosa Bonheur. Popular for her depictions of wildlife and domestic animals, Bonheur is a product of the 19th-century realism movement in which artists portrayed subject matter based on live observations, often in rural settings. Bonheur’s painting Elk (GM 0176.1228) in the Gilcrease collection demonstrates her skill in portraying wildlife. Another work in the Gilcrease collection, Indian Encampment (GM 0176.1229), was inspired by the Lakota cast members in Buffalo Bill’s Wild West, who performed in Paris in 1889. Bonheur’s work may also be found in the collections of the Musee d’Orsay in Paris, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Buffalo Bill Center of the West in the United States.
In general, women artist who portrayed the American West often challenged the romantic, masculine stereotypes contained in the prevalent western imagery of American pop culture and cinema. By creating a surreal composition by juxtaposing a mountain silhouette and animal skull, Georgia O’Keefe’s painting Antelope Head with Pedernal (GM 01.2521) challenges viewers to reconsider their views of the western landscape. Constance Whitney Warren’s sculpture William S. Hart demonstrates that she understood the twisting, active lines of a bucking horse as well as Frederic Remington in his sculpture The Bronco Buster (GM 0827.34).
In addition to American and European female artists, Gilcrease has collected art by Native American women working with various media. By working with both traditional and contemporary art forms, Native women are important to the development of Native American art history and expand the overall horizons of American art.
Promoting Native American art has always been at the forefront of the museum’s mission. Thomas Gilcrease himself established one of the first Native American artist-in-residence programs in the 1940s. However, while these roles were filled by male artists, the works Gilcrease collected by their female contemporaries like Maria Martinez helped establish a stronger voice for Native women artists in the 20th century. Through their efforts, Native female artists expanded concepts of Native American art. The Gilcrease collection includes works by Ella May Blackbear, Kay Walkingstick, Pablita Velarde, Norma Howard, Pop Chalee, and Leah Qumaluk.
In an ever-changing worldview toward class and gender roles how do we go about telling the stories of these women and their innovative contributions? Rather than merely slotting women artists into the standard cannon of art history, museums and galleries should consider setting aside the narrow, outdated canon and offer new, inclusive perspectives on American art.
By Zachary Qualls, Graduate Student, Museum Science and Management Program, The University of Tulsa, 2016
Black on black shallow ceramic bowl
Bowl -- Black on Black decorated shallow bowl signed by “Maria and Santana”; Maria Montoya Martinez (1887-1980) and her husband (Julian, 1885-1943) developed the technique of finishing black on black pottery. Santana is Maria’s daughter-in-law.
Read MoreIndian Encampment
Read MoreAntelope Head with Pedernal
Read MoreLedger Painting of Indians Stealing Military Horses
In Ledger Painting of Indians Stealing Military Horses, Virginia Stroud (Cherokee [United Keetoowah Band], Muscogee) depicts specific warriors on a coup raid to collect horses and other trophies from an invading colonial military group.
Read MorePrint A: Under the Oaks - Georgica Pond
Under the Oaks — Georgica Pond is one of Mary Nimmo Moran’s few ventures into producing etched works on a large scale. The plates used for most of the artist’s etchings measure around 7 1/2 by 11 1/2 inches. The plate for this work, however, measures a surprising 19 3/8 by 30 3/4 inches. Nimmo Moran liked to etch outdoors directly from nature, and she preferred using small plates easily held in her hands.1 Moreover, etched works became popular with collectors because of their small size: the owner could hold the print while closely examining all of its intricacies. By the late 1880s, however, the fondness for small etchings waned among collectors, and larger works for prominent display in the home became the trend.2
Read MoreMedicine Woman
Medicine Woman by Ruthe Blalock Jones (Delaware, Shawnee, Peoria) calls attention to the modest yet profound roles played by women within the Native American Church (NAC). Blalock Jones was raised in the NAC, and this artwork acknowledges a connection between her personal experience and the shared experiences of medicine women. Blurring the lines between realism and the Flatstyle techniques that became synonymous with Indigenous art produced in Oklahoma in the early twentieth century, Medicine Woman provides an intimate, first-person commentary that illuminates the interplay between presence and absence, between hypervisibility and invisibility in the portrayal of femininity and ceremonial space.
The medicine woman is shown kneeling in active prayer in the tipi. Blalock Jones centers the woman and frames her colorfully while still obscuring her face, for modesty, with a finely beaded ceremonial feather fan with thinly twisted buckskin fringe. The background is a smooth canvas tipi wall supported by dark and weathered poles. The ground line is formed by a comfortable and abundant array of brightly colored trade prayer blankets.
The woman is dressed in an unpresuming midnight-blue ankle-length frock and Plains-style high-top moccasins. A red and yellow beaded barrette holds her long gray hair in place. In a nod to the trade economies that fueled nineteenth-century Indigenous fashion trends, Blalock Jones has dressed her in an intricately adorned blue shawl with red silk fringe, which appears to cascade over the contours of her clothing.
—Jordan Poorman Cocker, Henry Luce Foundation Curatorial Scholar for Indigenous Painting Collection Research, 2021
Pueblo Craftsmen, Palace of the Governor Santa Fe
Read MoreWilliam S. Hart
Read MoreThe Home Pasture
Read MorePrint A: Summer, East Hampton
Read MoreFor John Ridge
Read MoreChristmas Eve, Torchlight Procession, Taos Pueblo
Read MoreThe New Scholar
Read MorePortrait of an Italian Lady
Read MoreUnidentified title
Read MoreOval double walled buckbrush basket
Oval, double woven basket in blond and reddish brown buckbrush. Made by Ella Blackbear.
Read MoreLong Horns Watering on Cattle Drive
This is a reference image scanned from an older transparency.
Read MoreA Little Uncertain
Read MoreOctober Brilliance
Read MoreCorralling the Ponies
Many horses in foreground and one dog and a mounted rider. Taos pueblo in background
Read More